Are Puck Screens Worth It?

Are Puck Screens Worth It?

Puck prep is a huge deal, and for a good reason; those fleeting moments before you tamp and lock your portafilter in to rip a shot straddle the line between an espresso that can change your life or make you spit in disgust. At a glance, puck screens seem like weird accessories, and they don’t give any indication of their value just by looking at them. At its core, the humble puck screen is just a metal filter. But what exactly is this tiny metal filter doing, and is it worth adding to your espresso routine? Let’s break it down.

Reducing Channeling 

One less dragon to slay is always a good thing. The biggest reason to add a puck screen to your routine is that it helps reduce channeling. It initially sounds far-fetched, but the logic checks out here. In the Clive office, we spend so much time perfecting puck prep—distributing, leveling, tamping—to ensure water flows evenly through the coffee. Yet, what about the head space between the shower screen and the coffee bed? What strange alchemy is going on there? Your machine’s group head determines how water is dispensed, and if that flow isn’t perfectly even, all your puck prep won’t save the shot. Since adding the puck screen to our normal puck prep routine, our daily shots have improved immensely. 

LUCCA Puck Screen lifestyle by Clive Coffee

Think of a puck screen as a second shower screen. It adds another layer of diffusion, ensuring that water spreads evenly across the coffee bed. Fewer opportunities for water to force its way through weak spots in the puck lead to more consistent extractions. A more even water distribution also reinforces the integrity of the coffee bed. Instead of the initial drops of water disturbing the top layer of coffee exclusively, the screen slows the flow, keeping everything intact.

Lastly, puck screens are relatively affordable and don’t require any modifications to your espresso machine, making them one of the easiest ways to improve your espresso routine. Pairing a puck screen with a precision shower screen is a powerful one-two punch for even water distribution.

Keeping Your Machine Clean

Puck screens have a less glamorous but equally useful benefit for those obsessed with a pristine setup: they help keep your machine cleaner. Since they sit directly on the espresso puck, they prevent stray grounds from floating into your group head and shower screen. In the short term, this means less residue affecting your next shot. Depending on how much coffee you make per day, it potentially means slightly longer intervals between deep cleans and backflushing. This is a net good for folks with E61 machines that benefit from less detergent backflushing. Backflushing detergent is amazing at stripping coffee oils, but it also strips the lubricant that makes your brew lever function smoothly. Want to avoid a crunchy brew lever? Use a puck screen. 

If you’ve ever had a puck partially stick to your shower screen, you know the frustration of having to manually clean it before pulling another shot. With a puck screen, that’s one less thing to worry about. Plus, a cleaner puck means a cleaner knock-out—no more stubborn, soggy messes in the portafilter.

Of course, the trade-off is that you now have to clean the puck screen itself. Fortunately, it’s a quick fix. For a heavier mesh screen (like our LUCCA puck screens), a quick blast of hot water from your machine’s water arm does the trick. Thinner screens can usually be rinsed under the sink like those included with Weber baskets. And for those who contend that cleaning a puck screen is much easier than removing and scrubbing a shower screen, you’re 100% correct on that. 

Should You Get a Puck Screen?

Yes! It's easy to add to your repertoire, keeps your shower screen clean, and reduces channeling. Still, puck screens tend to divide espresso enthusiasts. Some see them as unnecessary, while others wouldn’t dream of pulling a shot without one. We forced ourselves to use a puck screen for an entire week, and we see where the love comes from. There’s something deeply satisfying about knowing you’re doing everything possible to set up a great shot—kind of like mise en place for espresso.

What are your thoughts on puck screens? Do you use one? Have you given it a go but given up? Sound off in the comments. 

Get the Gear: