Single Boiler Comparison

Single Boiler Comparison

The specs look alike, the reviews are great, so how does one choose between four very similar single-boiler espresso machines? This short side-by-side comparison shows the workflow of each machine from initial start-up to pouring a latte. When you boil things down (pun intended) to machines this great, the difference in functionality and quality of coffee is subtle. We’ll highlight notable details and spec variances to factor into your decision. 

ECM Special Edition Classika PID — $1599

ECM Special Edition Classika PID Espresso Machine Eureka Mignon Silenzio Black Espresso grinder

Classika Specifications

  • PID / Shot Timer: Yes
  • Pre-infusion: No
  • Group Head: E61
  • Pump Type: Vibratory 
  • Water Source & Size: Reservoir Only, 3L
  • Boiler Size & Material: 0.75L, Stainless Steel
  • Size & Weight: 15.75”H x 10”W x 17.75”D , 41lbs

Classika Workflow

  • Initial heat up: 5:30 minutes for PID to reach brew temp of 200°F. *We recommend running water through the group head and allowing up to 10 minutes to ensure the machine is fully heated.
  • Heat to steam: 2:00 minutes for PID to reach steam temp of 255°F. *Once the machine reaches 255°F, purge water from the steam wand for about 10 seconds or until the water turns to steam. Allow the PID to reach 255°F before steaming a pitcher of milk. This can take up to one minute. 
  • Milk steaming: 25 seconds to steam 5oz of milk
  • Return to brew: 1 minute. *Once steaming is complete, turn off the steaming switch to return to brewing mode. You need to turn on the pump switch to refill the boilers and open the steam wand or group head (or both), allowing pressure to escape and the steam to turn back into water. If you bypass this step, the machine can take up to 10 minutes to cool down on its own. It will take about one minute for PID to reach 200°F.

What it Means

The Classika has the looks and features of our favorite dual-boiler espresso machines  — an E61 group head, brew lever, PID, and joystick steam knob. Out of the four machines, the Classika requires more steps between milk steaming and brewing but is perfect for the espresso purist making an occasional cappuccino. 

ECM Casa V — $999

ECM Casa V Espresso Machine Eureka Mignon Silenzio Espresso Grinder

Casa V Specifications

  • PID / Shot Timer: No
  • Pre-Infusion: No
  • Group Head: Saturated
  • Pump Type: Vibratory 
  • Water Source & Size: Reservoir Only, 3L
  • Boiler Size & Material: 0.4L, Brass
  • Size & Weight: 14.50”H x 8.25”W x 13.5”D , 31lbs

Casa V Workflow

  • Initial heat up: 2:45 minutes until heating light turns off.*We recommend running water through the group head and allowing up to 10 minutes to ensure the machine is fully heated.
  • Heat to steam: 1:15 minutes for heating light to turn off. *Purge water from the steam wand for about 5 seconds or until the water turns to steam. 
  • Milk steaming: 25 seconds to steam 5oz of milk
  • Return to brew: 1:45 minutes. *Once steaming is complete, press the steam button to return to brewing mode. Open the steam wand or group head (or both), allowing pressure to escape and the steam to turn back into water. If you bypass this step, the machine can take up to 10 minutes to cool down on its own. The heating light will turn off when it’s ready to brew.

What it Means:

The Casa V by ECM has unbeatable build quality and reliability. Though it doesn’t have a PID, you can trust the machine’s heating light to let you know when it’s time to pull shots and steam milk. A great first machine that can last a long time.

Lelit Victoria — $1099

Lelit Victoria Espresso Machine Eureka Mignon Silenzio Espresso Grinder

Lelit Victoria Specifications

  • PID / Shot Timer: Yes
  • Pre-infusion: Yes
  • Group Head: Saturated
  • Pump Type: Vibratory 
  • Water Source & Size: Reservoir Only, 2.7L
  • Boiler Size & Material: 0.3L, Brass
  • Size & Weight: 15”H x 9”W x 11”D , 21lbs

Lelit Victoria Workflow

  • Initial heat up: 7:30 minutes for PID to reach brew temp of 200°F and read OK. *We recommend running water through the group head and allowing up to 10 minutes to ensure the machine is fully heated.
  • Heat to steam: 1:30 minutes for PID to reach steam temp of 255°F. *Once the machine reaches 255°F, purge water from the steam wand for about 5 seconds or until the water turns to steam.
  • Milk steaming: 25 seconds to steam 5oz of milk
  • Return to brew: 45 seconds. *Once steaming is complete, press the brew button to return to brewing mode. Open the steam wand or group head (or both), allowing pressure to escape and the steam to turn back into water. If you bypass this step, the machine can take up to 10 minutes to cool down on its own. It will take about 45 seconds for PID to reach 200°F and read OK.

What it Means:

The Lelit Victoria is compact and packed with features — programmable PID and shot timer, and pre-infusion, more than any other single boiler we carry. Its precise temperatures allow the espresso enthusiast an opportunity to perfect their espresso recipe.

Rancilio Silvia — $830

Rancilio Silvia Espresso Machine Eureka Mignon Silenzio Espresso Grinder

Silvia Specifications

  • PID / Shot Timer: No
  • Pre-Infusion: No
  • Group Head: Saturated
  • Pump Type: Vibratory 
  • Water Source & Size: Reservoir Only, 2L
  • Boiler Size & Material: 0.3L, Brass
  • Size & Weight: 13.75”H x 9.25”W x 11.5”D , 35lbs

Silvia Workflow

  • Initial heat up: 4:00 minutes until heating light turns off. *We recommend running water through the group head and allowing up to 10 minutes to ensure the machine is fully heated.
  • Heat to steam: 2:45 minutes for heating light to turn off. *Purge water from the steam wand for about 5 seconds or until the water turns to steam. 
  • Milk steaming: 20 seconds to steam 5oz of milk
  • Return to brew: 2:00 minutes. *Once steaming is complete, press the steam button to return to brewing mode. Open the steam wand or group head (or both), allowing pressure to escape and the steam to turn back into water. If you bypass this step, the machine can take up to 10 minutes to cool down on its own. Wait until the heating light turns on and turns back off to ensure the machine is at a proper brewing temperature. 

What it Means:

Out of the four machines, the Silvia takes the longest to switch between milk steaming and coffee brewing but boats the quickest milk steaming. Even with a smaller boiler, it had the most steam power, making milk frothing quick and easy. The machine is minimal, yet powerful, and at an approachable price point, making it a great first machine.